
Most tax disputes with the IRS are settled during audits, collection proceedings and appeals — long before the need for litigation.
But sometimes, disagreements with the IRS land taxpayers in federal court. A tax litigation case can result from any form of taxation, from income to local property taxes. And these legal proceedings don’t just impact individual taxpayers, but businesses and estates, as well.
Litigation may result in penalties, fees, jail time or (best-case scenario) dismissal for the accused party. But what triggers litigation in the first place?
Here are 5 common reasons for tax litigation:
- Accuracy-related penalties. According to the IRS, this type of penalty applies when underpayment is shown on a return. For example, a deduction or credits may be claimed when the party doesn’t qualify, or total income is not reported. Challenging an accuracy penalty usually starts with an IRS auditor before seeking the last resort — heading to court.
- Summons enforcement. These disputes arise when a taxpayer doesn’t comply with an IRS request for information, usually stemming from an audit or investigation. A summons is issued, forcing the taxpayer to procure the necessary paperwork.
- Trade or business expense From home office costs to interest deductions, these cases are usually identified during an IRS audit. In most instances, the taxpayer doesn’t have documentation to substantiate an expense, but they can attempt to rectify the penalty by presenting their case to the IRS.
- Failure to file/pay penalties. These issues are typically the result of a taxpayer not submitting sufficient information or properly maintaining tax records, rather than willful neglect to file and pay. A taxpayer can wipe the slate clean by demonstrating that the error is due to reasonable cause.
- Frivolous issues. The IRS constitutes a frivolous argument as any in which a taxpayer makes a nonsensical dispute about the validity of the tax code. For example, they may challenge a collection issue by citing that the tax code is illegal. The best way for taxpayers to avoid these cases? Stick to the facts.
Evading the courthouse
If you’re involved in a tax dispute, we recommend speaking with a knowledgeable tax professional to guide you through IRS procedures and come to a resolution — outside of court. But sometimes, it’s necessary for the case to be further litigated.
If you have questions on any tax-related issues, don’t hesitate to contact the experts at Magone & Company




